New Movie Bottle Shock reminds us how far California Wine has come
Monday, August 25th, 2008Through the middle of the 20th Century, there was little question as to where the greatest wines were made – it was France. Although some California wineries had been producing wine since the 19th century, the French still had the best wines in the world. Even the White House served only French wines right up through the 1960s. It was then that the decree was made: only American wines would be served at the White House. It was thought to be a nice gesture but not a great culinary one. However this perception changed radically in 1976, with a wine tasting in Paris that caused an earthquake across the Wine world.
This famous tasting event is highlighted in a new film called Bottle Shock (as well as a second film called Judgment in Paris, which is still in development). Bottle Shock looks lovingly at winemakers in Napa Valley in the early and mid-1970s, highlighting the creation of the great Chateau Montelena Chardonnay that shook the wine world. The movie is a treat for wine lovers; gorgeous cinematography of Napa and wine country, and the inside story on making great wine. It builds up nicely to the 1976 Paris tasting that was a remarkable upset by Napa wines over French. Organizers had assumed that the French wines would easily win. They didn’t.
It’s important to know that all of the tasters of this legendary event were French wine experts, wine-makers and culinary writers, and included the secretary general of the Association des Grands Crus Classes. This was a blind tasting, so they didn’t know what was being poured. After the judging for the White wines, the event’s organizer Steve Spurrier, (brilliantly played in the Film by Alan Rickman) knew that the California whites had won, and against decorum informed the French tasters: not only had they chosen a California wine for the top prize, but that 3 out of 4 of the top white winners were Californian. In preparation for the Reds, the tasters were determined to choose a French winner, as they made remarks about “lesser quality US” wines. When the Red Wine tasting results were in though, the winner was from Napa Valley!
This historic event provides the highlight of Bottle Shock which was enthusiastically received at the Napa Valley premier in July, and is now in limited release. Comparisons to the great wine film Sideways are inevitable, but whether Bottle Shock reaches that wide an audience remains to be seen. They are radically different films, but Bottle Shock has all the important elements of a great movie – drama, challenges, family, love, and of course, lots of wine!